Bill 9: At a Glance
Bill 9 proposes to eliminate legal vacation rentals in Maui’s apartment districts — but at what cost?
Bill 9: A Brief Overview
Bill 9 could phase out short-term rentals in Maui’s Apartment Districts. This proposal has far-reaching consequences for families, businesses, and the island’s economy.Bill 9 was introduced by Mayor Richard Bissen and proposes phasing out Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in the Apartment Districts (A-1 and A-2), also known as the Minatoya list.The stated purpose of this bill is to address Maui’s housing crisis. However, the measure does not ensure that these units would ever become available or accessible for local residents.What Bill 9 does guarantee is significant harm to:Local families who rely on STR incomeSmall businesses that depend on visitor spendingMaui County’s economy, workforce, and tax revenues
Bill 9 puts thousands of local jobs and businesses at risk.
If passed, Maui will see fewer visitors, less spending in our economy, and fewer customers walking through the doors of local shops, restaurants, and services. This isn’t just about tourism — it’s about the families and workers who keep our communities alive.
Impacts on Businesses and Workers
Reduced Visitor Spending: Maui could lose $900M–$1.6B annually, cutting revenue from restaurants, shops, tours, and services.
Jobs Lost: Thousands of local jobs are at stake — many held by Maui residents who rely on tourism to support their families. Conservative estimates suggest at least 1,900 jobs could be lost, though the real number is likely far higher.
Business Closures: Restaurants, tour companies, and local services could face fewer customers, forcing some to shut down.
Lower Worker Earnings: Worker income could drop by hundreds of millions annually, making it harder for families to pay bills and mortgages.
Ripple Effect: Job losses or reduced income mean less money circulating at grocery stores, auto shops, and other local businesses.
Tax Revenue Loss: Maui County could collect $60M–$137M less each year, reducing resources for schools, parks, and essential services.
Housing Reality: Despite its intent, this bill offers no assurance that housing will actually be made available to local families. In cities like New York, Lake Tahoe, and Oʻahu, similar phase-outs have failed to make housing more affordable or accessible.
Take Action.
Maui’s future depends on the voices of our community. Business owners, workers, and families — your input matters.
Here’s how you can help:📞 Contact Your Council Member – Share why Bill 9 would hurt Maui’s families, businesses, and economy.
📝 Take the Advocacy Survey – Tell us how this bill could affect your business, your work, and your family. COMING SOON.
Stay Informed. Share Your Voice.
We’ll send you important updates on Bill 9, upcoming hearings, and ways you can make your voice heard. Your information will remain private and only be used for Bill 9 updates.
This page is provided by concerned members of the Maui community.